929 Sycamore Ave - Redevelopment Opportunity
929 Sycamore St
Buffalo, NY 14212
Highlights
- 16,983+/- SF
- Former Transfiguration Church
- Redevelopment Opportunity
Description
The former Transfiguration Church, a striking late 19th-century Gothic Revival structure, offers investors a rare high-risk, high-reward redevelopment opportunity. While the building has suffered significant deterioration, including roof collapse and structural damage, architectural and engineering-stamped plans are already in place to transform the site into a residential development concept featuring approximately 14 apartments while preserving the historic exterior shell. The redevelopment narrative calls for an estimated $6.3 million project budget, with projected monthly gross rents of $2,800 per unit and annualized income in excess of $700,000, providing the potential for strong long-term returns once stabilized. Rising assessed valuations, favorable preservation economics, and the potential eligibility for historic tax credits strengthen the investment case. For the right investor, this property represents a landmark adaptive reuse play—one that pairs visionary upside with substantial redevelopment challenges, offering a truly unique addition to Buffalo’s ongoing urban revitalization. Due to the sellers involvement on this project for the last five years he would prefer to stay involved in the development after closing.
929 Sycamore Street is strategically located in Buffalo’s East Side, just minutes from Downtown Buffalo and directly accessible to major regional roadways including the Kensington Expressway (NY-33), the I-190, and I-90, providing seamless connections throughout Western New York and into Canada. The property sits less than two miles from the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus—home to world-class hospitals and research institutions including Oishei Children’s Hospital, Buffalo General Medical Center, and Roswell Park Cancer Institute—and only a short drive from Canisius College, SUNY Buffalo State, and the University at Buffalo’s downtown campus. High-profile destinations such as KeyBank Center, Sahlen Field, and the LECOM Harbor Center are also nearby, reinforcing the property’s strong locational draw. Surrounded by residential neighborhoods, emerging redevelopment projects, and diverse cultural communities, the site benefits from both its central position in Buffalo’s urban grid and proximity to workforce, housing demand, and future growth drivers.
