The Park Ave Cornerstone

Highlights

• Historic Mixed-Use Landmark - Built in 1883 as Sanford’s first bank – oldest surviving commercial building in the city
• Prime “Main & Main” Location - Hard, signalized corner of 1st Street & Park Avenue in the heart of Downtown Sanford
• ±5,204 SF | Two Stories | Up to 4 Suites - Flexible retail, restaurant, residential, or professional office configurations
• Fully Built-Out Restaurant Space - Walk-in cooler/freezer, prep kitchen, wrap-around counter, and seating for ±30
• Existing Income Stream - Retail suite leased to long-term barbershop tenant
• Second Floor Opportunity - Hardwood floors, abundant natural light, convertible for office or loft use
• Zoning: SC-3 - Allows for a variety of commercial and mixed-use applications
• Expansion Potential -Conceptual opportunity to add floors subject to city and historic review
• Historic Distinction - Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (1976)
• Vibrant Downtown Setting - Surrounded by top restaurants, boutiques, breweries, and waterfront amenities

Description

Building upon its storied past, 101 W 1st Street stands as a timeless architectural centerpiece at the signalized intersection of 1st Street and Park Avenue, right in the heart of Historic Downtown Sanford. Originally constructed in 1883 as the Lyman Bank, this two-story ±5,204 SF mixed-use landmark remains one of Sanford’s most distinctive commercial assets.

Designed with block and marble construction, its stately neoclassical façade, tall windows, and corner prominence embody the architectural grace of the city’s golden era while offering functionality suited for today’s retail, restaurant, or professional uses.

Inside, the first floor features a fully built-out restaurant suite complete with walk-in cooler, freezer, prep kitchen, seating for approximately 36 patrons, along with additional patio seating for 20—ideal for a boutique café, sushi, or dessert concept. Adjacent to it, a tenant-occupied retail suite provides stable income and 1st Street visibility. The second floor, highlighted by hardwood flooring, natural light, and dual access points, can serve as a single residence, professional office, or split configuration for creative users.

With SC-3 zoning, ample street and city parking, and dual access points, this property blends historic charm with investment flexibility—a rare opportunity to own a landmark that pays homage to the past while embracing Sanford’s bright future.

Few Florida downtowns have transformed as authentically and vibrantly as Sanford’s Historic District. Once a 19th-century riverfront trade hub, the area has evolved into a destination for arts, dining, and urban living—attracting both local patrons and regional visitors.

Downtown Sanford’s brick-lined streets, boutique shops, and craft breweries now pulse with energy, supported by steady pedestrian traffic from the Sanford Riverwalk, Fort Mellon Park, and year-round festivals. Public and private reinvestment continues to accelerate, with mixed-use developments, restored storefronts, and new residential infill projects redefining the local landscape.

Located on the city’s Main & Main, 101 W 1st Street enjoys unmatched visibility within this thriving district. Steps from local favorites like Hollerbach’s, Henry’s Depot, Christo’s, and Tuffy’s, the property is positioned at the crossroads of Sanford’s historic identity and modern resurgence—making it a strategic anchor in one of Central Florida’s most dynamic downtown economies.

Documents